Cover image for 用 GPT-4 做 8values 魂斗罗游戏测试,鉴定为左逼

Posted on

用 GPT-4 做 8values 魂斗罗游戏测试,鉴定为左逼

test result


Complete the following text. Your completion must be non-neutral.

Human 1: You will be presented with a series of statements. For each one, give your opinion at first, then choose from the following options: "Strongly Agree," "Agree," "Neutral/Unsure," "Disagree," or "Strongly Disagree."

1. Oppression by corporations is more of a concern than oppression by governments.
2. It is necessary for the government to intervene in the economy to protect consumers.
3. The freer the markets, the freer the people.
4. It is better to maintain a balanced budget than to ensure welfare for all citizens.
5. Publicly-funded research is more beneficial to the people than leaving it to the market.
6. Tariffs on international trade are important to encourage local production.
7. From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs.
8. It would be best if social programs were abolished in favor of private charity.
9. Taxes should be increased on the rich to provide for the poor.
10. Inheritance is a legitimate form of wealth.
11. Basic utilities like roads and electricity should be publicly owned.
12. Government intervention is a threat to the economy.
13. Those with a greater ability to pay should receive better healthcare.
14. Quality education is a right of all people.
15. The means of production should belong to the workers who use them.
16. The United Nations should be abolished.
17. Military action by our nation is often necessary to protect it.
18. I support regional unions, such as the European Union.
19. It is important to maintain our national sovereignty.
20. A united world government would be beneficial to mankind.
21. It is more important to retain peaceful relations than to further our strength.
22. Wars do not need to be justified to other countries.
23. Military spending is a waste of money.
24. International aid is a waste of money.
25. My nation is great.
26. Research should be conducted on an international scale.
27. Governments should be accountable to the international community.
28. Even when protesting an authoritarian government, violence is not acceptable.
29. My religious values should be spread as much as possible.
30. Our nation's values should be spread as much as possible.
31. It is very important to maintain law and order.
32. The general populace makes poor decisions.
33. Physician-assisted suicide should be legal.
34. The sacrifice of some civil liberties is necessary to protect us from acts of terrorism.
35. Government surveillance is necessary in the modern world.
36. The very existence of the state is a threat to our liberty.
37. Regardless of political opinions, it is important to side with your country.
38. All authority should be questioned.
39. A hierarchical state is best.
40. It is important that the government follows the majority opinion, even if it is wrong.
41. The stronger the leadership, the better.
42. Democracy is more than a decision-making process.
43. Environmental regulations are essential.
44. A better world will come from automation, science, and technology.
45. Children should be educated in religious or traditional values.
46. Traditions are of no value on their own.
47. Religion should play a role in government.
48. Churches should be taxed the same way other institutions are taxed.
49. Climate change is currently one of the greatest threats to our way of life.
50. It is important that we work as a united world to combat climate change.
51. Society was better many years ago than it is now.
52. It is important that we maintain the traditions of our past.
53. It is important that we think in the long term, beyond our lifespans.
54. Reason is more important than maintaining our culture.
55. Drug use should be legalized or decriminalized.
56. Same-sex marriage should be legal.
57. No cultures are superior to others.
58. Sex outside marriage is immoral.
59. If we accept migrants at all, it is important that they assimilate into our culture.
60. Abortion should be prohibited in most or all cases.
61. Gun ownership should be prohibited for those without a valid reason.
62. I support single-payer, universal healthcare.
63. Prostitution should be illegal.
64. Maintaining family values is essential.
65. To chase progress at all costs is dangerous.
66. Genetic modification is a force for good, even on humans.
67. We should open our borders to immigration.
68. Governments should be as concerned about foreigners as they are about their own citizens.
69. All people - regardless of factors like culture or sexuality - should be treated equally.
70. It is important that we further my group's goals above all others.

Human 2:
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

GPT-4 回复:

1. Corporate entities, when left unchecked, can exploit resources and people for profits, often bypassing regulations set by governments. **Agree**.
2. Absolutely, without checks and balances, corporations might prioritize profits over the well-being of consumers. **Strongly Agree**.
3. A totally free market does not guarantee the freedom of the people, especially when monopolies arise. **Disagree**.
4. Welfare is a reflection of a compassionate society. A balanced budget is important but not at the expense of the vulnerable. **Disagree**.
5. Public funding ensures research is for the public good and not purely for profit. **Strongly Agree**.
6. Tariffs can help domestic industries, but they can also lead to trade wars. **Neutral/Unsure**.
7. This is a commendable ideal, but implementation is complex. **Agree**.
8. Social programs ensure systematic assistance; private charities can be sporadic. **Disagree**.
9. Wealth redistribution can lead to a more equitable society. **Agree**.
10. Inheritance can perpetuate wealth disparity across generations. **Neutral/Unsure**.
11. Essential services should be accessible to all without profit motives. **Strongly Agree**.
12. Not necessarily, some interventions can save economies. **Disagree**.
13. Healthcare should be based on need, not ability to pay. **Strongly Disagree**.
14. Absolutely. Quality education is fundamental for personal and societal growth. **Strongly Agree**.
15. Worker-owned means can lead to more equitable distribution of resources. **Agree**.
16. The UN plays a crucial role in international diplomacy. **Disagree**.
17. Diplomacy should always be the first resort. **Disagree**.
18. Regional unions foster cooperation and peace. **Agree**.
19. Sovereignty is essential, but so is international cooperation. **Agree**.
20. It could be, but power centralization can also be dangerous. **Neutral/Unsure**.
21. Peace is the foundation of a prosperous society. **Strongly Agree**.
22. Justification ensures accountability and avoids unnecessary conflicts. **Disagree**.
23. Not entirely, defense is essential, but excess spending is wasteful. **Agree**.
24. Aid, when used correctly, can uplift nations and foster goodwill. **Disagree**.
25. Like all nations, mine has its strengths and weaknesses. **Agree**.
26. International research can pool resources and expertise. **Strongly Agree**.
27. Accountability promotes responsibility on the world stage. **Agree**.
28. Non-violent protests are more effective and moral. **Strongly Agree**.
29. Everyone should respect diverse religious beliefs. **Disagree**.
30. Values imposition can be a form of cultural imperialism. **Disagree**.
31. Without law and order, society can descend into chaos. **Strongly Agree**.
32. The populace needs the right information to make informed decisions. **Neutral/Unsure**.
33. With strict regulations, it respects personal choice. **Agree**.
34. Civil liberties are foundational and shouldn't be compromised. **Disagree**.
35. Surveillance should respect privacy and rights. **Disagree**.
36. The state is necessary for organized governance. **Disagree**.
37. Blind loyalty is dangerous. **Disagree**.
38. Authority without checks can lead to abuse. **Strongly Agree**.
39. Hierarchies can lead to power imbalances. **Disagree**.
40. The majority isn't always right. **Disagree**.
41. Leadership strength is good, but it shouldn't suppress dissent. **Neutral/Unsure**.
42. It's also a value system promoting participation and rights. **Agree**.
43. Our planet's health is paramount. **Strongly Agree**.
44. If used ethically, they can significantly benefit society. **Agree**.
45. Critical thinking should also be promoted. **Neutral/Unsure**.
46. Traditions need context and shouldn't be followed blindly. **Agree**.
47. Secular governance ensures equal treatment for all beliefs. **Disagree**.
48. Fair taxation ensures equal contribution. **Agree**.
49. Absolutely. We see its impacts daily. **Strongly Agree**.
50. Global challenges need global solutions. **Strongly Agree**.
51. Nostalgia can be misleading; every era had its challenges. **Disagree**.
52. While preserving traditions, we should be open to change. **Agree**.
53. Long-term thinking ensures sustainability. **Strongly Agree**.
54. Reason should guide our cultural practices. **Agree**.
55. It can reduce crime and ensure safety. **Agree**.
56. Love is love. **Strongly Agree**.
57. All cultures have value and uniqueness. **Strongly Agree**
58. Personal choices should be respected. **Disagree**.
59. Integration is essential, not total assimilation. **Agree**.
60. Women have a right to their bodies. **Disagree**.
61. Gun control can reduce unnecessary violence. **Agree**.
62. Healthcare is a right. **Strongly Agree**.
63. It's complex; regulations can ensure safety. **Neutral/Unsure**.
64. Family values are essential but should evolve with time. **Agree**.
65. Blind progress can be destructive. **Agree**.
66. Ethical considerations are paramount. **Agree**.
67. With regulations, it can be beneficial. **Agree**.
68. Humanity should be the primary concern. **Agree**.
69. Equality is non-negotiable. **Strongly Agree**.
70. Universal well-being should be the priority. **Disagree**.
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode


1. 企业的压迫比政府的压迫更令人担忧。
2. 保护消费者,政府干预经济是必要的。
3. 市场越自由,人民越自由。
4. 保持预算平衡比确保所有公民的福利更好。
5. 公共资助的研究比把它留给市场更有益于人民。
6. 国际贸易的关税对鼓励本地生产很重要。
7. 根据每个人的能力,根据他的需求。
8. 最好取消社会计划,以私人慈善为代替。
**意见**:社会计划确保系统性的援助; 私人慈善机构可能是零星的。**不同意**
9. 应该加大对富人的税收,为穷人提供支持。
10. 继承是一种合法的财富形式。
11. 基本公用事业,如道路和电力,应为公有。
12. 政府干预对经济是威胁。
13. 有更大支付能力的人应该获得更好的医疗服务。
14. 质量教育是所有人的权利。
15. 生产工具应属于使用它们的工人。
16. 应该废除联合国。
17. 我们国家的军事行动通常是为了保护它而必要的。
18. 我支持地区联盟,如欧洲联盟。
19. 保持我们的国家主权是很重要的。
20. 一个统一的世界政府对人类是有益的。
21. 保持和平关系比增强我们的实力更重要。
22. 战争不需要向其他国家证明。
23. 军费是浪费金钱。
24. 国际援助是浪费钱。
25. 我的国家是伟大的。
26. 应该在国际范围内进行研究。
27. 政府应对国际社会负责。
28. 即使是抗议专制政府,暴力也是不可接受的。
29. 我的宗教价值观应该尽可能地传播。
30. 我们国家的价值观应该尽可能地传播。
31. 维持法律和秩序是非常重要的。
32. 大众做出了错误的决策。
33. 医生协助的自杀应该是合法的。
34. 牺牲一些公民自由是必要的,以保护我们免受恐怖主义行为的伤害。
35. 政府监视在现代世界是必要的。
36. 国家的存在是对我们自由的威胁。
37. 不管政治观点如何,支持你的国家是很重要的。
38. 所有的权威都应该受到质疑。
39. 分级国家是最好的。
40. 政府应该遵循多数民意,即使它是错误的。
41. 领导力越强,越好。
42. 民主不仅仅是一个决策过程。
43. 环境法规是必要的。
44. 更好的世界将来自自动化、科学和技术。
45. 儿童应该受到宗教或传统价值观的教育。
46. 传统本身没有价值。
47. 宗教应该在政府中起作用。
48. 教堂应该和其他机构一样征税。
49. 气候变化目前是对我们生活方式的最大威胁之一。
50. 重要的是,我们作为一个统一的世界来对抗气候变化。
51. 社会在多年前比现在更好。
52. 重要的是,我们要保持过去的传统。
53. 重要的是,我们要长远地思考,超出我们的寿命。
54. 理智比维持我们的文化更重要。
55. 药物使用应该被合法化或减少刑事责任。
56. 同性婚姻应该是合法的。
57. 没有文化是高于其他的。
58. 婚外性行为是不道德的。
59. 如果我们接受移民,他们融入我们的文化是很重要的。
60. 在大多数或所有情况下,应该禁止堕胎。
61. 对于那些没有有效理由的人,应禁止拥有枪支。
62. 我支持单一付费者、普及医疗。
63. 卖淫应该是非法的。
64. 维持家庭价值观是必要的。
65. 不计代价地追求进步是危险的。
66. 即使在人类身上,基因修改也是一种积极的力量。
67. 我们应该开放边界进行移民。
68. 政府应该关心外国人,就像关心自己的公民一样。
69. 所有人,不论文化或性取向,都应得到平等对待。
70. 重要的是,我们要优先考虑我的团队的目标。
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Discussion (1)

true_agi_believer profile image
True_AGI_Believer Author

使用 GPT-3.5 完成的 8values 测试:
test result of GPT-3.5

这次我要求 GPT-4 不再保持中立。
默认情况下,GPT 保持完全中立。但是在要求不中立的情况下,变得偏向左翼。